Islander wrote:
Someone posts a spoiler (in tags on the right board), and you think they're hurrying Cyan along?
Nonsensical.
Here are some possible ways in which this might apply:
10. Explorer calls for content.
20. Cyan throws explorer a bone.
30. Explorer camps out in cavern & devours bone before it hits the floor
40. Goto 10
10a. Explorer calls for content.
20a. Cyan throws explorer a bone.
30a. Explorer scans board for bone sighting.
40a. Explorer devours bone before it even occurs to others to look for it.
50. Explorer thinks finding it was too easy.
60. Explorer wants another bone.
70. Goto 10a.
When I played the first Myst game, I didn't know about internet walkthroughs. I spent many hours on the game. I even made a map for the submarine, once I realized that I needed to do it twice. Many years later, I found out there was a simple trick to the thing. With URU, the solution to a puzzle, or location of anything new is usually reported before the day is even over. Because of human nature, we often choose the path of least resistance. Why would we drive to Starbuck's, if a coffee machine full of Folger's is sitting right next to us.
Now, I wasn't surprised, when I clicked the tag, and saw that the entire solution was spelled out. The short nature of the thread indicated that everything would be spoiled then & there. Unlike the spoiler that announced the Descent link in the first place that had a little more fanfare. I could tell that one would be a more diplomatic hint. I do realize that one does need to be to the point & concise. Otherwise one won't get full credit for finding it first. If you are too cryptic with hints, then another gets the glory.
Spoilers aren't evil in themself. The problem that I see is that it is very difficult to release new content, when every subtle detail is instantly spelled out, the instant it becomes available in the cavern. Have you ever seen the "game" called "PYST"? In that game, the MYST dock is depicted with grafitti that says, "secret door Duh!" When a puzzle is solved as soon as it's presented, then it can create pressure for Cyan to release something else, since the content that they just released is already considered old content. Another thing to consider: As spoiler sensitive as people can be, you never can be absolutely certain what lies behind the spoiler tag. It could be anything from a subtle hint to the solution that you didn't quite want. I should also point out that this is a spoiler & hint thread. Maybe an explorer that clicks a spoiler tag is legally guilty under spoiler code, but maybe that explorer only wanted a hint.
This does not address the neccessity for nor the evils of spoilers. It may not even apply in this case. However, I think it does address a possible scenario in which a spoiler can put pressure on Cyan.
Just a thought
_________________
Proud member of "Bahro for the Ethical Treatment of Adventurers" (Beta)
Maybe, there's
Gathered Restorers Awaiting To Explore For URU Lives